Comparisons · 5 min read

Asphalt Emulsion vs. Refined Coal Tar: Your Sarasota Sealcoating Showdown

Choosing the right Sealcoating for your Sarasota driveway is important. It is not just about the color. It is about protecting your investment from the strong Sarasota sun and the heavy rain we get here. The Sarasota climate can be brutal on asphalt surfaces. Paradise Asphalt Inc. wants to help homeowners and business owners in Sarasota make an informed decision. We will explain the two main types of Sealcoating so you can understand them better.

← Back to Blog Completed asphalt sealcoating work at a residential property in Sarasota, FL

Alright, let us talk about driveways. You have an Asphalt Driveway here in Sarasota, FL, and it needs protection. Our Florida sun, the relentless humidity, and those sudden heavy downpours are very brutal on pavement. Sealcoating is not just a cosmetic fix; it is important maintenance to keep your Asphalt Driveway from crumbling faster than a sandcastle in a hurricane. But when it comes to picking a sealcoat in Sarasota, FL, you have options, and not all of them are created equal, especially for our unique Sarasota climate.

Paradise Asphalt Inc. has seen many driveways come and go in Sarasota, FL. The choice between Asphalt Emulsion and Refined Coal Tar sealers comes up constantly for Paradise Asphalt Inc. Homeowners often do not realize there is a big difference in Sarasota, FL, so let us dive into what you need to know about Asphalt Driveway Sealcoating.

Asphalt Emulsion Sealcoat: The Modern Choice for Sarasota, FL

This is what most people are using these days for their Asphalt Driveways in Sarasota, FL, and for good reason. Asphalt Emulsion Sealers are made from refined asphalt, water, and often include polymers and other additives. Think of it as a water-based paint for your Asphalt Driveway in Sarasota.

Cost of Asphalt Emulsion Sealcoat in Sarasota, FL

Generally, Asphalt Emulsion tends to be a bit more expensive upfront per gallon than Coal Tar. However, the overall cost of Asphalt Emulsion Sealcoat can be competitive when you factor in the application and the long-term value for your Sarasota, FL, home.

Durability and Maintenance of Asphalt Emulsion Sealcoat

Modern Asphalt Emulsions have come a long way. They are flexible, which is a very big plus here in Florida where our pavement expands and contracts with the heat. This flexibility helps prevent cracking on your Asphalt Driveway. Asphalt Emulsion Sealcoat offers good protection against UV rays and water damage, which is exactly what we need in Sarasota, FL, to combat our intense sun and heavy rains. You will typically need to reapply Asphalt Emulsion every 1 to 3 years, depending on traffic and weather conditions in Sarasota.

Appearance of Asphalt Emulsion Sealcoat

Asphalt Emulsion dries to a rich, deep black color. This really enhances your home's curb appeal in Sarasota. It gives that fresh, new pavement look to your Asphalt Driveway.

Environmental and Health Considerations for Asphalt Emulsion Sealcoat in Sarasota, FL

This is where Asphalt Emulsion really shines for Sarasota, FL, homeowners. It is considered the more eco-friendly choice because it is water-based and contains significantly fewer harmful chemicals. Specifically, it has fewer Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) compared to Coal Tar. PAHs are important because they can be toxic to aquatic life and have been linked to health concerns. With Sarasota being so close to the Gulf and our numerous waterways, minimizing runoff of these chemicals is important. Many areas across the country have even banned Coal Tar Sealants due to environmental concerns.

Refined Coal Tar Sealcoat: The Traditional Option for Sarasota, FL

Coal Tar Sealers are made from a byproduct of coal processing. For a long time, this was the go-to for Sealcoating, especially in commercial applications in Sarasota, FL.

Cost of Refined Coal Tar Sealcoat in Sarasota, FL

Historically, Coal Tar has often been less expensive per gallon than Asphalt Emulsion. However, its availability is tightening due to regulations, which can impact pricing for Sarasota, FL, homeowners.

Durability and Maintenance of Refined Coal Tar Sealcoat

Coal Tar is known for its exceptional durability and resistance to chemicals like oil and gasoline spills. It forms a very hard surface when cured. This hardness, however, can be a double-edged sword, especially in our Sarasota climate. While it resists wear, it can become brittle over time and may crack. This cracking allows water to penetrate the Asphalt Driveway. It typically lasts 3-5 years, sometimes longer in ideal conditions.

Appearance of Refined Coal Tar Sealcoat

Coal Tar also provides a deep, rich black color that many people find appealing for their Asphalt Driveways in Sarasota, FL.

Environmental and Health Considerations for Refined Coal Tar Sealcoat in Sarasota, FL

This is the main drawback for Coal Tar Sealcoat. It contains high levels of PAHs, which are known carcinogens and environmental contaminants. These PAHs do not stay on the pavement; they can wash off into stormwater. This impacts local ecosystems, especially our precious Sarasota Bay and interconnected water bodies. Because of these concerns, many states and municipalities have banned or restricted its use.

Paradise Asphalt Inc. Recommendation for Sarasota, FL, Homeowners

Look, Paradise Asphalt Inc. is a contractor, and our job is to give you the best advice for your property in Sarasota, FL. Considering our specific conditions here in Sarasota, FL – the intense sun, heavy rain, and our proximity to sensitive waterways – Paradise Asphalt Inc. strongly recommends Asphalt Emulsion Sealcoat for residential Asphalt Driveways.

  • It is the more environmentally responsible choice, which is a big deal when we live so close to the Gulf and our beautiful beaches in Sarasota.
  • The flexibility of modern Asphalt Emulsion is better suited to handle our temperature fluctuations in Sarasota without becoming brittle and cracking.
  • While you might reapply it a little more often than the longest-lasting Coal Tar, the peace of mind knowing you are not introducing harmful chemicals into your yard or local environment is priceless for your Sarasota home.
  • Plus, the appearance of Asphalt Emulsion Sealcoat is fantastic, giving you that fresh, dark finish you want for your Asphalt Driveway in Sarasota.

You want an Asphalt Driveway Sealcoat that protects your investment, looks great, and does not cause problems down the line. Asphalt Emulsion delivers on all fronts, especially for homeowners in Sarasota, FL. If you are looking for a reliable Asphalt Driveway Sealcoating job that stands up to the Sarasota elements, give Paradise Asphalt Inc. a call. Paradise Asphalt Inc. will make sure your Asphalt Driveway is protected the right way in Sarasota, FL.

Ready to Get Started in Sarasota?

Contact Paradise Asphalt Inc today for a free, no-obligation estimate on your project.

Get Your Free Quote